Visual Quality

Tested in both dark and light modesResponsive at all breakpoints (mobile, tablet, desktop)Consistent spacing (follows space-y-* system)Typography follows scale (no ad-hoc sizes)Colors use semantic tokens (no raw values)

Interaction

All interactive elements have hover statesFocus states are visible (focus-visible:ring)Loading states implemented (skeletons, spinners)Empty states designed (no data scenarios)Error states handled gracefully

Accessibility

Keyboard navigable (Tab, Enter, Escape)Color contrast passes WCAG AA (4.5:1)Icon-only buttons have aria-labelForm inputs have associated labelsStatus indicators have text alternatives

Performance

Images optimized (WebP, compressed)No layout shift on load (CLS)Heavy components lazy loadedNo unnecessary re-rendersAppropriate staleTime for API calls

Code Quality

Follows component structure patternUses React Query for data fetchingNo inline styles (use Tailwind classes)No magic numbers (use design tokens)Consistent naming conventions

Design Review Checklist

Visual Quality

Interaction

Accessibility

Performance

Code Quality

Ready to ship?